Opening Soon

Sunset & Oak is preparing for launch. The menu and pricing shown here are a preview and may change before ordering opens.

Whole cuts, cooked low over live fire, a few at a time.
Reserved ahead. Never held. Never rushed.

Morris County · New Jersey · Pre-order only · Drive-up pickup

Text to order · Coming soon
SUNSET & OAK Where the fire is lit
The Name

Named for the corner where the fire burns.

Sunset & Oak isn’t a brand someone dreamed up in a conference room. It’s an address — the corner where the pit sits and the fire gets lit. Every butt, rack and bird on this page comes off that one fire, cooked by one set of hands, in batches small enough that nothing is ever an afterthought.

At the fireMarc A. Reynolds, Pitmaster

Small batchLimited slots each cook. When they’re gone, they’re gone.
Whole cutsBone-in, full racks, whole birds. Nothing portioned off a steam table.
Cooked to orderYour order is on the fire because you reserved it.
How It Works

Reserve it. We light it. You pick it up fresh.

There’s no walk-in counter and no tray of leftovers from yesterday. The fire is sized to the orders on the books — that’s the whole point.

Reserve your slotPick your quantities, then text us your order. Cook slots are limited and fill in the order received.
Confirm & prepayWe confirm by text with payment details. Your order is locked in once it’s paid.
The cookNo two cooks are the same — every fire is planned around the weather and that week’s orders. That’s why everything is reserved in advance.
Pick up — without leaving your carDrive-up handoff at your scheduled window. Every cook is timed to your pickup — arrive on time and it comes to you hot off the fire, wrapped and resting, with reheat notes in the bag.

Orders are prepaid and final once confirmed — we buy and prep specifically for your order. Weights are pre-cook; fire-cooked meat naturally loses 30–45% of its raw weight. Butt and rib sizes vary slightly by what the butcher has that week; we always round up, never down.

At Home

Keep it like it left the fire.

Serving within the hour

Leave it wrapped. Put the whole package in a dry cooler with a towel on top — it will stay warm for two to three hours.

Serving later

Wrapped in foil, 250°F oven until the center reaches 165°F: about 60–90 minutes for a butt, 25–35 for ribs and birds.

Pulling the butt

Twist out the blade bone, pull into chunks — not threads — and pour the reserved juices back over the meat before serving.

Sunset & Oak

Order ticket
Tap a quantity on any item above and it lands here.
Bone-In Boston Butt$77 ea
Full Spare Ribs (St. Louis)$48 ea
Baby Back Ribs$42 ea
Spatchcock Chicken$36 ea
Whole Chicken$36 ea
Smoked Wings (12)$22 ea
Barbecue Glaze$5 ea
Specialty Sweet Glaze$5 ea
Estimated total
Ordering coming soon

Orders by text only · Coming soon
No calls, please.

Ordering opens soon. Until then, build your order here to see your total — nothing is charged.

Your order · items
Coming soon